Lobsterville Beach offers generally calmer swimming conditions compared to other Aquinnah beaches due to its location on Menemsha Pond and Vineyard Sound. The waters are typically gentler with smaller waves, making it suitable for families. However, always check for current conditions and posted warnings. There are no lifeguards on duty, so swim at your own risk. The beach has both pond-side and ocean-side access, with the pond side being shallower and warmer. Be mindful of currents near the channel entrance where the pond meets the sound.

Lobsterville Beach is accessible year-round, but summer months (June through September) offer the warmest weather and water temperatures. However, the beach is particularly renowned for spectacular sunsets, viewable any season. Late spring and early fall provide fewer crowds while still offering pleasant conditions. Summer weekends can get busy, so arriving early is recommended. For the best sunset experience, check local sunset times and arrive 30-45 minutes early to secure parking and a good viewing spot. Off-season visits offer solitude and excellent beachcombing opportunities.

Lobsterville Beach is located off Lobsterville Road in Aquinnah on Martha's Vineyard's western shore. From Menemsha, head north on Lobsterville Road for approximately two miles. Parking is available in a small dirt lot at the beach entrance, but spaces are limited and fill quickly during summer months and sunset hours. The lot is free but can accommodate only about 20-30 vehicles. Alternatively, many visitors bike from nearby Menemsha or other towns. No public transportation serves the beach directly, so having a car or bicycle is essential.

Lobsterville Beach has no facilities, restaurants, or amenities directly on site. There are no restrooms, showers, or concessions available. Visitors should bring all necessary supplies, including water, snacks, and sun protection. The nearby fishing village of Menemsha, about two miles south, offers several seafood restaurants, a market, and public restrooms. For accommodations, the closest lodging options are in Menemsha, Chilmark, and Aquinnah, though advance reservations are essential during summer months. Pack out all trash as there are no garbage facilities at the beach.

Lobsterville Beach faces west over Vineyard Sound, providing unobstructed sunset views across the water. Its position offers a clear horizon line where the sun appears to sink directly into the ocean, creating dramatic color displays reflecting off the water. The beach's relatively undeveloped shoreline enhances the natural beauty without light pollution or structural interference. Many photographers and locals consider it one of Martha's Vineyard's premier sunset-viewing locations. The combination of open sky, water reflections, and occasional sailboats passing creates postcard-worthy scenes, especially during summer when the sun sets over the water.